Orange County, CA Lender Liability Lawyer
Practice Areas
Experienced Lender Liability Attorneys Serving Clients Across Southern California
A loan agreement carries legal obligations on both sides of the transaction. Borrowers are required to repay their debt according to the agreed terms, but lenders are equally bound by duties of honesty, good faith, and fair dealing. When a lender steps outside those boundaries through fraud, misconduct, or a breach of their legal obligations, the borrower may have grounds for a lender liability claim.
Marshack Hays Wood LLP is an experienced Orange County lender liability law firm representing both lenders and borrowers in complex lending disputes throughout California. Our attorneys have achieved significant recoveries on behalf of lending institutions, and we have equally deep experience representing borrowers who have been harmed by lender misconduct. We also have extensive experience negotiating with lenders and secured creditors in Chapter 11 bankruptcy cases — helping debtors-in-possession cure defaults, adjust interest rates, reduce security interests, and reorganize secured debt.
Whether you are a lender seeking to enforce your rights or a borrower who has suffered harm at the hands of a credit union, bank, or other financial institutions, Marshack Hays Wood has the knowledge, experience, and resources to represent your interests effectively. To speak with an experienced lender liability attorney in Orange County, CA, call our office at 949-333-7777 or click the link below to schedule a consultation today.
The Rights and Responsibilities of Lenders in Orange County
The lender-borrower relationship is built on a foundation of trust, communication, and mutual obligation. Borrowers must make timely payments and fulfill the terms of their loan agreements. Lenders, in turn, must treat borrowers fairly, adhere to the terms of the loan documents they prepare, and comply with the legal and regulatory framework governing their conduct.
At the outset of a lending relationship, financial institutions negotiate and prepare loan documents that define the terms and conditions of the agreement. Once those documents are executed, both parties are bound by them. In many lending relationships, particularly where the lender also serves in an advisory capacity, the law imposes a fiduciary duty on the lender, requiring them to act in the borrower’s best interests and not merely in the lender’s own financial interest.
What is Lender Liability?
Lender liability is a body of law that governs the obligations lenders owe to borrowers and the legal consequences when those obligations are not met. At its core, lender liability law recognizes that the relationship between a lender and a borrower is not simply a commercial transaction. It is a relationship governed by contractual duties, fiduciary principles in certain circumstances, and an overarching obligation of good faith and fair dealing.
Lender liability laws became widely recognized in the 1980s and experienced a significant resurgence following the credit crisis of 2008, when widespread lending misconduct brought new attention to the legal rights of borrowers.
While many lender liability claims involve overly aggressive or improper collection efforts, the legal framework also covers a wide range of other misconduct, including breach of contract, improper foreclosure, fraudulent loan practices, and more.
Understanding Lender Liability Law in California
California lender liability law has evolved significantly over the years. An important recent development came on March 7, 2022, when the California Supreme Court issued its decision in Sheen v. Wells Fargo Bank, holding that lenders do not owe a tort duty of care to borrowers in connection with processing, reviewing, and responding to loan modification applications. This decision narrowed the scope of tort-based lender liability claims in California in the loan modification context.
However, the Sheen decision does not eliminate lender liability claims broadly. It addresses a specific category of tort claims and does not affect contractual claims, breach of fiduciary duty claims where a true fiduciary relationship exists, or claims arising from other forms of lender misconduct. Borrowers who have suffered harm as a result of a lender’s breach of obligations may still have strong and viable legal claims.
What is a Lender Liability Claim?
A lender liability claim arises when a borrower recognizes that a lender has engaged in unfair, fraudulent, or otherwise unlawful conduct in connection with a lending relationship. To establish a valid lender liability claim, the borrower must demonstrate several key elements:
- that the lender owed the borrower a duty — whether contractual, fiduciary, or statutory;
- that the lender breached that duty through specific conduct; and
- that the borrower suffered actual, quantifiable damages as a direct result of that breach.
What is Lender Liability Coverage?
Lender liability coverage is a form of errors and omissions insurance that protects lenders against claims arising from mistakes, negligence, misstatements, and other breaches of duty in the extension of credit. Just as individuals carry vehicle liability insurance to protect against potential accidents, lenders maintain this coverage to protect against the financial consequences of lender liability claims.
Types of Lender Misconduct & Lender Liability Issues
Borrowers can pursue lender liability claims for a wide range of misconduct. The following are among the most common types of claims that our lender liability attorneys see here at Marshack Hays Wood, LLP:
Breach of Contract / Breach of Loan Agreement
A breach of contract by a lender occurs when the lender fails to fulfill its contractual obligations under the loan’s terms. Lender liability arising from a breach of contract may include violations of the loan agreement itself, the lender’s fiduciary duty where one exists, the implied duty of good faith, and other legal obligations owed to the borrower under California law.
A breach of contract in a lender liability case can take many forms, including but not limited to:
- Failing to fund a loan that was committed
- Imposing terms that were not part of the original agreement
- Improperly declaring a default
- Failing to provide required notices
Borrowers who suffer financial harm as a result of a lender’s breach of the loan agreement have the right to pursue damages.
Breach of Fiduciary Duty
Not every lender-borrower relationship gives rise to a fiduciary duty, but when it does, the lender is held to a significantly higher standard of conduct. A fiduciary relationship may arise when a lender also acts as a financial advisor to the borrower, exercises control over the borrower’s financial decisions, or occupies a position of special trust and confidence. In a fiduciary relationship, the lender is obligated to prioritize the borrower’s interests. Failure to do so can give rise to a breach of fiduciary duty claim.
Breach of Implied Covenant of Good Faith
A breach of the implied covenant of good faith can arise when lenders act in bad faith by failing to treat their borrowers fairly, even if the written terms of the agreement appear to be followed. This type of misconduct may involve:
- Manipulating loan terms
- Withholding approvals
- Using tactics that undermine the borrower’s ability to benefit from the agreement, compared to how other lenders would reasonably act
Tortious Interference
Tortious interference can arise in a lender liability claim when a lender improperly disrupts a borrower’s existing or prospective business relationships. This may include actions such as:
- Interfering with contracts
- Discouraging third parties from doing business with the borrower
- Using leverage to influence outside agreements for the lender’s benefit
When these actions cause financial harm, the lender may be held liable for damages resulting from the interference.
Improper Foreclosures
Wrongful or improper foreclosure occurs when a lender initiates foreclosure proceedings without a valid legal basis or conducts the foreclosure process in a manner that violates California law. This can result from negligence, administrative errors, or deliberate misconduct. Common examples include:
- Foreclosing despite an active loan modification agreement
- Failing to provide required notices
- Proceeding with a non-judicial foreclosure in violation of statutory requirements
Borrowers who lose property to an improper foreclosure may be entitled to damages, and in some cases, to the return of their property. Our Orange County foreclosure defense lawyers at Marshack Hays Wood can help ensure that happens.
Loan Application Violations
Lenders can expose themselves to liability through misconduct at the loan origination stage, as well. Loan application violations may include:
- Fraudulent or manipulated property appraisals
- Misrepresentations in the loan application or underwriting process
- Discriminatory lending practices in violation of fair lending laws
- Breach of a loan commitment after the borrower has relied on it to their detriment
- Undue delays caused by improper application processing
- Steering borrowers toward higher-cost loan products for the lender’s financial benefit
- Requiring insurance products that are unreasonably expensive or unnecessary
Improper Collateral Sales
Lender liability claims may also arise from the improper handling or sale of collateral. California law imposes specific requirements on how and when lenders may take possession of and sell collateral — including requirements for commercially reasonable sales and fair appraisals. When a lender uses artificially low appraisals, fails to provide proper notice, or otherwise mishandles collateral in violation of applicable rules, the borrower may have a valid claim for damages arising from the improper sale.
FAQs Regarding Lender Liability Lawsuits
Can You Sue a Lender for Negligence?
The ability to sue a lender for negligence in California has been affected by recent case law (Sheen v. Wells Fargo Bank), which limited lenders' tort duty of care in the loan modification context. However, negligence claims against lenders remain viable in a number of circumstances outside the scope of that decision.
When a lender does specific actions or makes specific representations that the borrower reasonably relies upon to their detriment, negligence and negligent misrepresentation claims may still be pursued. Additionally, claims grounded in contract, breach of fiduciary duty, and statutory violations remain fully available and are often more powerful tools than negligence claims in lender liability litigation. An experienced lender liability attorney can assess the specific facts of your situation and identify the strongest available legal theories for your claim.
Can I Sue My Lender for Not Closing on Time?
Yes. In many circumstances, a lender's failure to close a loan on time can give rise to a valid legal claim. When a lender commits to funding a loan by a certain date and fails to do so, the borrower may suffer significant financial harm, including the loss of a purchase opportunity, the incurrence of additional costs, damage to business relationships, or breach of the borrower's own contractual obligations to third parties.
Whether a failure to close on time constitutes an actionable breach depends on the specific terms of the loan commitment, the circumstances surrounding the delay, and whether the lender acted in good faith throughout the process.
What Happens If a Lender Sues You?
Lenders also have the right to pursue legal action against borrowers who default on their obligations. If you are on the receiving end of a lender's lawsuit, having experienced legal representation is more important than ever. Lender lawsuits against borrowers can take many forms, including actions to recover unpaid loan balances, judicial foreclosure proceedings, actions to enforce guarantees, and claims for breach of covenant violations under a loan agreement.
Being sued by a lender does not mean the lender's position is unassailable. Borrowers have a range of potential defenses available. This includes challenging the validity of the lender's claims, asserting counterclaims for lender misconduct, and raising procedural defenses if the lender has failed to comply with applicable legal requirements. In some cases, a borrower's counterclaims may be as powerful as the lender's underlying suit.
What is Private Lender Law in California?
Private lender law governs the rights and obligations of non-institutional lenders (e.g., private individuals, hard money lenders, and private equity funds) who extend credit outside the traditional banking system. In California, private lenders are subject to many of the same legal requirements as institutional lenders, including the duty to act in good faith, to adhere to the terms of their loan agreements, and to comply with applicable state and federal lending regulations.
However, private lending disputes are increasingly common in California's real estate and business financing markets, where private lenders play a significant role in providing capital that traditional banks will not. When disputes arise, the legal issues can be just as complex as those involving institutional lenders. Marshack Hays Wood has the experience to navigate private lending disputes effectively, whether you are a private lender seeking to enforce your rights or a borrower contesting improper conduct.
Why You Need an Experienced Lender Liability Attorney
Lender liability litigation is a highly specialized area of law that sits at the intersection of contract law, real property law, banking regulation, and, in many cases, bankruptcy law. The legal issues involved are often complex, the opposing parties are typically well-resourced institutions with experienced legal teams, and the financial stakes can be substantial. These disputes may also involve multiple parties, including other creditors, and can progress from early negotiations through discovery and ultimately to trial if a resolution is not reached.
Working with an experienced lender liability lawyer gives you access to attorneys who can advise plaintiffs and other parties on effective legal strategies from the outset. Skilled counsel understands how to investigate and document misconduct, build strong lender liability lawsuits, and present persuasive arguments in court.
Why Choose Marshack Hays Wood as Your Lender Liability Law Firm
Marshack Hays Wood is one of the most respected business litigation and bankruptcy law firms in Orange County, CA. Our lender liability lawyers have extensive experience representing financial institutions, private lenders, borrowers, companies, and other parties in lending disputes of all kinds — from straightforward breach of contract claims to complex multi-party litigation involving real property, secured debt, and bankruptcy proceedings.
Our attorneys have been at the forefront of California’s lending landscape through multiple economic cycles, including the 2008 financial crisis and its aftermath. We have represented clients in disputes involving RESPA, TILA, and HOEPA (the federal statutes that govern many aspects of residential mortgage lending) as well as in complex commercial lending disputes involving sophisticated financial products and structures.
What distinguishes our law firm is not just our legal knowledge but our approach. We are results-focused from the outset of every engagement, working to understand our clients’ goals, develop a clear, strategic path to achieve them, and execute that strategy with precision and tenacity. Whether a matter resolves through negotiation, mediation, or full litigation, Marshack Hays Wood’s lender liability lawyers leave no stone unturned in the pursuit of the best possible outcome for our clients.
Contact an Experienced Lender Liability Lawyer in Orange County Today
Lending disputes can be financially devastating and emotionally draining, whether you are a borrower who has suffered harm at the hands of a lender or a lender seeking to enforce your rights against a defaulting borrower. In either situation, having the right legal team makes all the difference.
At Marshack Hays Wood, our bankruptcy and business litigation attorneys in Orange County, CA bring decades of combined experience in both state and federal courts, including appellate courts, to every case we handle. We regularly represent both lenders and borrowers in Irvine, Anaheim, Santa Ana, Huntington Beach, Costa Mesa, and throughout Orange County and the surrounding Southern California communities.
To schedule a confidential consultation with an experienced Orange County, CA lender liability lawyer, call 949-333-7777 or contact us online today. The sooner you seek legal guidance, the better positioned you will be to protect your rights and pursue the outcome you deserve.
READY TO GET STARTED?
At Marshack Hays Wood, our attorneys provide the legal support you need to move forward with confidence. Let us help you take the first step toward financial stability.